pakistan nhi emigration

Photo: Pixabay

SA’s top medical group blasts NHI – as 4 in 10 doctors ‘now considering emigration’

This week, the SA Medical Association laid out its beef with the NHI proposals facing South Africa – and many doctors see emigration as their way out.

pakistan nhi emigration

Photo: Pixabay

The SA Medical Association (SAMA), which represents a large network of healthcare workers across South Africa, has reiterated its opposition to the National Health Insurance (NHI) scheme that has been proposed by the government – with 38% of surveyed members confirming their plans for emigration IF the policy becomes law.

Why NHI is so vehemently opposed in SA…

The push for free medical care across the board has its merits, but the practicalities of such a move could cause something of a medical nightmare for the country. Now Mzansi has been battered by a pandemic, the implementation of NHI stands at a crossroads – and SAMA are hoping that the ANC take a u-turn sooner rather than later.

According to a statement released this week, SAMA object to the following factors:

  • – The current ‘significant quality deficits’ in the public sector are likely to be incorporated into the new world of the NHI .
  • – Government has not made substantial strides to close the gap between public and private hospitals.
  • – SAMA oppose NHI’s policy of asylum seekers and illegal foreigners, who ‘will only be entitled to emergency medical services’.
  • – Children of undocumented followers may also be refused treatment – and SAMA are adamant that doctors DO NOT distinguish the need for care on the basis of legal status in the country
  • Much of the NHI detail will be in the Regulations and Rules which are yet to be developed, and therefore cannot be commented on.

Doctors in South Africa ‘still considering emigration’

SAMA have referred back to a survey taken just before COVID-19 washed up on South African shores. At the time, it showed that roughly 4 in 10 doctors wanted to leave Mzansi *specifically* due to the NHI proposals. It’s understood that those numbers have held true over the last year or so – leaving our healthcare system on an emigration knife-edge.

Emigration intentions are high amongst disgruntled doctors – Photo: SAMA
  • The survey in question, by the way, asked over 1 300 doctors what they thought about NHI. Their responses were glum:
There’s barely any support for NHI amongst most medical professionals – Photo: SAMA

Emigration or NHI? Doctors mull difficult decision

On Tuesday, SAMA made their objections crystal clear. On top of the aforementioned reasons to oppose NHI, there are also complaints that the Bill gives the Minister of Health ‘way too much power’.

“The South African Medical Association today reaffirmed its stance on the proposed National Health Insurance (NHI) during its submission to the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Health saying while it supports some provisions, others lack essential detail which has far-reaching consequences for NHI implementation.”

“SAMA cannot support the NHI Bill in its entirety. It gives the Minister of Health has too many unfettered powers in this structure. It further believes that the Fund should be accountable to the Department of Health and vice versa.”